NAPREC · Fact checks · Updated November 20, 2026Leer en español →
Puerto Rico Statehood Fact Checks
How we check: we compare claims about Puerto Rico’s status with the public record: laws, certified election results and official government data. Every answer below links to a NAPREC article that lists its sources. We check claims, not parties.
Latest fact check
Governor DeSantis is wrong: Puerto Rico’s voters have been asking for statehoodStatehood won the 2012, 2017, 2020 and 2024 plebiscites, 58.61% in 2024. Gallup found 66% national support in 2019. In 2018, then-Congressman DeSantis was an original cosponsor of the Puerto Rico Admission Act. Read the fact checkCommon claims, checked
Voting and Congress
Claim“Puerto Rico’s voters haven’t asked for statehood.”
RecordStatehood won the plebiscites of 2012, 2017, 2020 and 2024. In 2024 it received 58.61% of valid votes, nearly double free association (29.57%), according to Puerto Rico’s State Elections Commission.
More: Fact check: Governor DeSantis · Seven status votes, 1967–2024
Claim“Most Americans oppose statehood for Puerto Rico.”
RecordIn Gallup’s most recent survey on the question, in June 2019, 66% of U.S. adults favored admitting Puerto Rico as a state. Gallup reports majority support since the 1960s.
More: Fact check: Governor DeSantis · Polling and public opinion
Claim“Statehood is a one-party project.”
RecordIn 2018, H.R. 6246, the Puerto Rico Admission Act, had 58 cosponsors: 32 Democrats and 26 Republicans. In 2022 the Puerto Rico Status Act passed the House 233 to 191, with every Democrat and 16 Republicans voting yes (House roll call 529).
More: A bipartisan record · Why the Senate decides statehood
Claim“Puerto Rico already has a vote in Congress.”
RecordPuerto Rico elects one Resident Commissioner to the House, who serves on committees and introduces bills but cannot vote on the final passage of any bill. Puerto Rico has no senators.
More: The Resident Commissioner: a seat without a final vote
Claim“The Resident Commissioner can vote on the House floor like other members.”
RecordThe Resident Commissioner’s right to vote in the Committee of the Whole, where the House works on amendments, depends on each Congress’s rules: it was granted in 1993, removed in 1995, restored in 2007, removed in 2011 and restored in 2019. When those votes decide an outcome, the question is voted again without them. In none of these periods could the Resident Commissioner vote on final passage.
Claim“Congress has never voted on Puerto Rico’s status.”
RecordThe House passed status bills in 1998 (209 to 208), 2010 (223 to 169) and 2022 (233 to 191). The Senate has never voted on one, and its committee last held a hearing on Puerto Rico’s status on August 1, 2013.
Claim“A plebiscite can make Puerto Rico a state.”
RecordUnder Article IV, Section 3 of the Constitution, “New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union.” All 37 states admitted after the original 13 joined by a decision of Congress. A vote in a territory expresses its preference; Congress decides.
Claim“Puerto Ricans can vote for President.”
RecordResidents of Puerto Rico can vote in the parties’ presidential primaries, which both national parties held there in April 2024. They cannot vote in the general election: the Constitution gives presidential electors to the states, and the Twenty-third Amendment gives them to Washington, D.C. Puerto Rico has none. A Puerto Rican who moves to a state can vote for President there.
Taxes, debt and finances
Claim“People in Puerto Rico don’t pay federal taxes.”
RecordThe IRS collected $5.54 billion in gross federal taxes from Puerto Rico in fiscal year 2025 (IRS Data Book). Workers and employers pay Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes. Bona fide residents generally do not pay federal income tax on income from Puerto Rican sources, a rule Congress wrote for the territory.
Claim“Families in Puerto Rico can’t claim the federal Child Tax Credit.”
RecordSince tax year 2021, a family in Puerto Rico with one child can qualify; before, the refundable part was limited to families with three or more children. Families claim it by filing with the IRS, for example on Form 1040-PR, even though most bona fide residents report their Puerto Rico income to Hacienda instead.
Claim“Workers in Puerto Rico receive the federal Earned Income Tax Credit.”
RecordResidents of Puerto Rico generally cannot claim the federal credit, because they do not file federal income tax returns on their Puerto Rico income. Puerto Rico runs its own earned income credit. Since 2021, under the American Rescue Plan Act (26 U.S.C. § 7530), the federal government matches the cost above a base amount, up to three times that base.
More: Puerto Rico’s earned income credit and the federal match
Claim“Statehood would cost Puerto Rico its Section 936 tax break.”
RecordSection 936, enacted in 1976, gave U.S. corporations a credit equal to their federal tax on qualifying income earned in Puerto Rico. Congress capped it in 1993 and, in 1996, repealed it with a ten-year phase-out (Public Law 104-188). It expired completely on January 1, 2006, without any change in Puerto Rico’s status.
Claim“Puerto Rico must pay off its debt before it can become a state.”
RecordThe Texas State Library explains that Texas kept its public debt when it was annexed and became a state in 1845. Section 402 of PROMESA says the law should not be read to restrict Puerto Rico’s right to determine its future political status. Neither fact settles what financial terms Congress would choose.
Claim“Puerto Rico could have used bankruptcy, like Detroit.”
RecordSince a 1984 amendment, the Bankruptcy Code has excluded Puerto Rico when deciding who may be a Chapter 9 debtor, so its public corporations could not file. When Puerto Rico passed its own debt law in 2014, the Supreme Court held 5 to 2 in Puerto Rico v. Franklin California Tax-Free Trust (2016) that federal law barred it. Congress enacted PROMESA on June 30, 2016.
More: Puerto Rico v. Franklin
Claim“Puerto Rico’s voters chose the Oversight Board.”
RecordUnder PROMESA, the President selects the Board’s members, most from lists prepared by congressional leaders. In Aurelius (2020), the Supreme Court held that they did not need Senate confirmation because their duties concern Puerto Rico’s own finances. The Board can certify Puerto Rico’s budgets and fiscal plans over the objections of elected officials.
Federal programs
Claim“Low-income seniors and people with disabilities in Puerto Rico receive SSI like everyone else.”
RecordSupplemental Security Income is not paid in Puerto Rico; federal law limits it to the 50 states and the District of Columbia. A citizen who receives SSI in a state loses it on moving to the island. In United States v. Vaello Madero (2022), the Supreme Court held that the Constitution does not require Congress to extend SSI to Puerto Rico, leaving the decision with Congress.
Claim“Puerto Rico is left out of Social Security.”
RecordSocial Security treats Puerto Rico almost exactly like a state. Workers pay the same payroll taxes and earn benefits under the same formula. In December 2025, 851,795 people in Puerto Rico received Social Security benefits, about $1.05 billion that month (Social Security Administration). The program that excludes Puerto Rico is SSI, which is separate.
Claim“Puerto Rico’s Medicaid is funded the same way as a state’s.”
RecordIn the states, federal Medicaid matching has no fixed annual ceiling and follows a formula based on per capita income. Puerto Rico’s federal funds are capped under Section 1108 of the Social Security Act, and its matching rate is set in law. Its enhanced funding runs through September 30, 2027; unless Congress acts, the federal share would fall from 76% to 55%.
Claim“Puerto Rico receives SNAP like the states.”
RecordPuerto Rico was removed from the national food stamp program in 1982 and has received a capped block grant, the Nutrition Assistance Program, ever since. The U.S. Virgin Islands and Guam remain in SNAP. Unlike SNAP, a capped grant cannot grow automatically after a hurricane or a recession. Bills in both chambers would bring Puerto Rico into SNAP.
More: From NAP to SNAP
Law and history
Claim“The Constitution guarantees citizenship to people born in Puerto Rico.”
RecordPeople born in Puerto Rico are U.S. citizens at birth under a law passed by Congress, 8 U.S.C. § 1402. In a state, birthright citizenship rests on the Fourteenth Amendment. That difference is why bills on citizenship in the territories keep coming back to Congress.
More: Citizenship by statute
Claim“Puerto Rico is a foreign country.”
RecordIn De Lima v. Bidwell (1901), the Supreme Court held that after the Treaty of Paris, Puerto Rico was no longer a foreign country under the tariff laws. The same day, in Downes v. Bidwell, it treated Puerto Rico as belonging to the United States without being incorporated into it. Puerto Ricans have been U.S. citizens by statute since 1917.
More: De Lima and Downes
Claim“The Insular Cases are settled law that no one questions.”
RecordIn Vaello Madero (2022), Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote that the Insular Cases “rest on a rotten foundation”; Justice Sonia Sotomayor noted her agreement on that point. House Resolution 314 (2023) would reject them, and in July 2024 the Justice Department’s manual said their racist language and logic deserve no place in the law. The Supreme Court has not overruled them.
Claim“The Constitution’s protections don’t apply in Puerto Rico.”
RecordCore individual rights do apply. In Torres v. Puerto Rico (1979), the Supreme Court held that the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable searches applies there, and in Examining Board v. Flores de Otero (1976) it held the same for equal protection and due process. These rulings do not give Puerto Rico senators, a vote for President or a final vote in the House.
More: Torres v. Puerto Rico
Claim“The 1952 Constitution ended Puerto Rico’s territorial status.”
RecordThe constitution organized Puerto Rico’s local government, but Congress approved it only with changes that Congress required (Public Law 82-447). The relationship with the United States is still governed by the Territory Clause. In Puerto Rico v. Sánchez Valle (2016), the Supreme Court held that Puerto Rico’s prosecutorial authority ultimately derives from Congress.
More: The 1952 Constitution
Claim“Puerto Rico has always elected its own governor.”
RecordFor nearly half a century after 1898, the President appointed Puerto Rico’s governors, under the Foraker Act of 1900 and the Jones–Shafroth Act of 1917. The Elective Governor Act, signed on August 5, 1947, let voters choose the governor. Voters chose the first elected governor in November 1948, and the new governor took office in January 1949.
Claim“Federal judges in Puerto Rico don’t have the same independence as judges in the states.”
RecordUntil 1966, judges of the U.S. District Court for Puerto Rico served eight-year terms. Public Law 89-571, enacted on September 12, 1966, gave them the same life tenure and salary protections as federal judges in the states. What still differs: Puerto Rico has no senators to vote on confirming those judges.
Claim“Puerto Ricans don’t have the same military obligations as other Americans.”
RecordPuerto Ricans have served in the U.S. armed forces since early in the last century. Under the fiscal 2026 National Defense Authorization Act, Selective Service registration becomes automatic for men ages 18 to 25 starting in December 2026, in Puerto Rico as in the states. When the House passed that bill 312 to 112, Puerto Rico’s Resident Commissioner could not vote on final passage.
People
Claim“Most Puerto Ricans live in Puerto Rico.”
RecordThe Census Bureau estimated Puerto Rico’s population at 3,184,835 on July 1, 2025. Its American Community Survey for 2020–2024 counts about 5.96 million people of Puerto Rican origin in the 50 states, including about 1.25 million in Florida and about 1.0 million in New York. In the states, they vote for President and elect voting members of Congress.
More: Puerto Rico and its diaspora in the latest Census estimates
Claim“Hurricane María killed 64 people.”
RecordThat was the official count for nearly a year. On August 28, 2018, the Governor adopted as the official figure a study by George Washington University’s Milken Institute School of Public Health, with the University of Puerto Rico, which estimated 2,975 excess deaths from September 2017 through February 2018 (range 2,658 to 3,290).
More: Counting the dead
How NAPREC checks a claim
We quote the claim as it was made and link to where it appeared. We check it against primary sources, such as the text of a law, certified results or official data, and we say when the record does not settle a question. NAPREC supports statehood, and we label our position separately from the facts. To report an error, please contact us.
NAPREC Editorial Team · Updated November 20, 2026 · See also Puerto Rico statehood: the complete guide and Statehood pros and cons.

